If you're searching for an unforgettable dining experience in the heart of Mt. Sinai, look no further than Rocco's Pizzeria & Ristorante. This beloved pizza restaurant has earned its reputation for serving up some of the most mouthwatering pizzas in town, with an inviting atmosphere that feels just like home.
At Rocco's, the aroma of freshly baked, artisanal pizzas fills the air, beckoning you to dive into a culinary journey that celebrates traditional Italian flavors. The menu boasts an enticing array of Brick Oven Pizzettes that are sure to impress, including fan favorites like the Margherita Pizzetta, known for its vibrant and fresh tomato and basil combination, and the rich and creamy Pizzetta Alla Vodka, a must-try that leaves you craving more. For those seeking something special, the Rocco’s Special Pizzetta and The Godfather Pizzetta promise to deliver a delightful explosion of flavors with every bite.
But it's not just pizza that shines at Rocco's. Their entrees also deserve a spotlight, with options like the Balsamic Fried Chicken that boasts a perfect balance of crispy and tender, and the savory Eggplant Parmigiana for the vegetarians in your group. Pair your meal with their Sicilian or Grandma-style pizzas for a true Italian feast.
Customers rave about the quality and taste; whether it’s the nostalgic rainbow Italian ices or the highly-praised Grandma Alla Vodka Pizza featuring sausage crumble and a drizzle of hot honey, everyone finds a dish to fall in love with. Local patrons like Lyzzette Lopez and Mel S have consistently highlighted their experiences, with Lyzzette proclaiming Rocco's vodka sauce Grandma Pie as “unbelievably good,” while Mel expressed the joy of repeatedly returning for the consistent quality and deliciousness. Each visit feels like reuniting with family.
The family-friendly ambiance at Rocco's adds to the allure, creating a welcoming spot for casual dining or special celebrations. It's a place where you can indulge in a “cheat meal” without the guilt, as expressed by Shelley Smith, who relished their crispy thin crust and ample, delectable sauce. Paired with friends, family or even during a catered event, Rocco’s consistently delivers on excellence. Whether you’re ordering pizza for delivery or dining in, the friendly staff ensures that every request is met with a smile, adding to the warm, inviting vibe of this neighborhood gem.
Rocco's Pizzeria & Ristorante is not just a place to eat; it's a culinary experience that brings people together over delicious food. Don't miss out on the chance to savor their delectable offerings. Call ahead at +1 631-928-5892 and get ready to indulge in a slice of happiness!
Your insights help other diners decide. We’ll keep your email private. Required fields are marked *
Lyzzette Lopez
13/12/2025
We order their vodka sauce Grandma Pie with pepperoni for delivery often because it’s so unbelievably good. Very pleasant staff to deal with and their food is excellent.
Mel S
03/11/2025
My mom and I have gotten delivery from this place more times than I can count. The food is amazing. I’ve tried so many things from the menu and they never disappoint. Current favorites are the 12” margarita pizza & 12” alla vodka pizza, eggplant rolatini, mozzarella sticks, Buffalo chicken roll. Don’t forget they have rainbow Italian ices too, how nostalgic :)
Dawson Realty Team
17/10/2025
We had a recent event catered with Rocco’s and everyone was raving about the food. The penne ala vodka, eggplant rollatini, sausage and peppers and chicken francese are all great choices if you’re catering. And Nick was awesome with all the setup!
Josh Aprile
08/09/2025
They have the best Grandma alla Vodka, with susage crumble and hot honey, just perfection, outstanding.
Shelley Smith
03/09/2025
My husband and I have been dieting for 2 months now and we decided it was time to have a “cheat” meal and pizza was the natural choice. We ordered a large cheese pie and we weren’t disappointed. The crust was thin and crispy….the sauce was ample and delicious…..the cheese was so good with an amazing cheese pull! We were so happy we chose Rocco’s for our pig out fest! We will be back for sure for the next cheat day. Rocco’s is also clean and the customer service is A+
Paul Gippetti
31/08/2025
Pizza here is legit. If you’re looking for a good slice, this is the spot. Classic, crispy, no flop, and loaded with flavor. Can’t go wrong with it.thank you !!!!
Dina D
23/08/2025
Rocco's catered a party for us, and everything was great! Friendly staff, delicious and plentiful food, and fair prices. We will definitely be ordering from Rocco's again.